• About us
  • Raising the Bar
  • Raising your Game
  • The Extra G - Geopolitical
  • Risk Matters - Roundtables
  • Leadership Team
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Menu

The Risk Coalition

  • About us
  • Raising the Bar
  • Raising your Game
  • The Extra G - Geopolitical
  • Risk Matters - Roundtables
  • Leadership Team
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Contact

Are young people increasing the risk profiles of banks?

March 08, 2022

Is the way young people use financial services changing the risk profile of financial service providers?

It’s an intriguing question since there’s no doubt that young people are indeed interacting with banks, pension funds and other financial service providers very differently from the way their parents or grandparents did. Gone are the days when a young person would open an account with one of the major high street banks – filling in forms in person, over the counter – and then gradually build up a portfolio of financial products, reflecting their professional and personal journey – a current account, a savings account, an overdraft to buy a car, a pension plan, a mortgage to buy a house, life insurance, and so on.

That’s a simplified view, of course, but even allowing for over-generalisation we have to recognise some fundamental differences in the way in which younger people are using financial products.

Most obviously, they are interacting digitally, over phones and tablets, and see little point in time-consuming face-to-face contact. Intuitively, one would say that this enhances risks around cyber-security, increasing the vulnerability of customers and institutions to fraud and theft from outsiders. But one has to be careful here. Digitally savvy young people are well aware of the risks around cyber-security – probably far more so than older users. (My 12 year old daughter, who is a long way from buying her first investment product, has already had numerous lessons in school about staying safe over the internet.) So, if we’re going to blame digitalisation for increasing cyber risks in banks, we probably ought to focus on risky behaviour by the older generation rather than by young people.

Secondly, the emergence of small specialised financial service firms, particularly those engaged in investment management, money transfer, and small-denomination credit, enable customers to spread business over multiple providers. Historically, customer acquisition has been expensive for the high-street banks, which is why cross-selling to existing customers was so important for profitability. Not only does digital finance greatly reduce the cost of customer acquisition while also facilitating customer acquisition by new digitally-based firms, but public policy around ‘open-banking’ is reducing the value of the accumulated information on customers that the high street banks enjoy while also reducing customer inertia in the face of competitive offerings from rival firms.

So, the notion of a ‘financial services supermarket’, cross selling to customers and providing a significant proportion of their financial needs, is increasingly outdated. We are looking at a more variegated landscape in which customers interact with a variety of financial institutions, and switch between them more frequently than in the past.

That begs the question of whether the inherent profitability of financial services will increase or decrease in this more volatile market. Is a residential mortgage still profitable if the customer switches to another provider after five years? Can banks charge enough for current accounts without pushing clients into the arms of start-ups who are willing to loss-lead during their first few years?

We have to keep all this in perspective. Banks have been trying to poach their rivals’ residential mortgage customers, by offering ‘teaser rates’, for more than 20 years. The notion that a current account is free of fees and charges was abandoned many years ago. Yet the big banks have continued to make money, with their profitability more dependent on global interest rates, economic cycles and periodic crises, than the slow and incremental changes in the cost of financial products.

New generations of young people have been changing society’s relationship with traditional high street banks for decades, and most of those high street banks are still with us.

The dangers of historical myopia – ‘this time it’s different’ – are huge.

I wonder if we are missing the bigger picture here.

What we can assert with confidence that there are some fundamental changes to life and work patterns occurring as a result of increased life expectancy and an unwillingness of firms to fund generous pension plans.

Young people in western Europe can expect to live until they are at least 90 years old. They will have to work longer in order to fund a retirement that will also be longer. They will have to retrain, or upgrade their skills, during the course of their working lives, perhaps taking time out of paid employment to do so. Meanwhile, younger people are entering the work force later (often with debts due on student loans) and are less likely to enjoy employer contributions to a pension fund.

So, the real threat that young people present to financial institutions lies not in the way that they use financial products, nor in changes to the inherent profitability of the products themselves, but in the increased financial vulnerability of young people themselves. It’s going to be much harder for young people to acquire capital to fund their retirement, or an investment in late-life education, than it was for their parents or grandparents.

If young people are becoming less financially secure, then, as a class of customers, they present greater risks to banks.

And this is not simply a risk factor for financial institutions – it is a challenge for public finance and society as a whole.

 

Andrew Cunningham is the founder and managing director of Darien Analytics Limited, a UK-based consulting firm that focuses on risk, regulation and governance in both developed and emerging markets. He is also a Visiting Professor at the London Institute of Banking and Finance.

Tags: Andrew Cunningham
Prev / Next

Blog

Featured
Apr 15, 2025
Vera Cherepanova
The future of ESG: navigating a fragmented landscape
Apr 15, 2025
Vera Cherepanova
Apr 15, 2025
Vera Cherepanova
Mar 6, 2025
Mo Warsame, Gavin Hayes
Internal audit and risk management must work together to navigate uncertainty
Mar 6, 2025
Mo Warsame, Gavin Hayes
Mar 6, 2025
Mo Warsame, Gavin Hayes
Sep 4, 2024
Polly Williams, Mia Harris
Three key threats of phishing to be aware of
Sep 4, 2024
Polly Williams, Mia Harris
Sep 4, 2024
Polly Williams, Mia Harris
Aug 25, 2024
Felix Ritchie
Principles versus rules in data and corporate governance
Aug 25, 2024
Felix Ritchie
Aug 25, 2024
Felix Ritchie
Jul 16, 2024
Jane Hunter, Mia Harris
How can you maintain high standards in your business without suffering burnout?
Jul 16, 2024
Jane Hunter, Mia Harris
Jul 16, 2024
Jane Hunter, Mia Harris
Jun 2, 2024
Afshan Moeed
Enforcement of individual accountability in UK banking: a new boardroom recipe for change or continuity?
Jun 2, 2024
Afshan Moeed
Jun 2, 2024
Afshan Moeed
May 28, 2024
Craig Morris, Mia Harris
Three exciting new developments for AI in 2024 that you need to know about
May 28, 2024
Craig Morris, Mia Harris
May 28, 2024
Craig Morris, Mia Harris
May 24, 2024
Stefan Hunziker
The stuff of nightmares: risk management is shut down, and nobody notices
May 24, 2024
Stefan Hunziker
May 24, 2024
Stefan Hunziker
Mar 20, 2024
Neil Tinegate
What should boards know about digital technology?
Mar 20, 2024
Neil Tinegate
Mar 20, 2024
Neil Tinegate
Mar 15, 2024
Francis Kean
The insolvency risk for company directors - are you swimming naked?
Mar 15, 2024
Francis Kean
Mar 15, 2024
Francis Kean
Feb 29, 2024
Andy Watkins-Child
Are you sitting comfortably?  Cyber risk, board attestations and the implications for NEDs
Feb 29, 2024
Andy Watkins-Child
Feb 29, 2024
Andy Watkins-Child
Oct 24, 2023
Mamun Madaser
Risk management and internal audit should collaborate to navigate the poly-crisis of risk
Oct 24, 2023
Mamun Madaser
Oct 24, 2023
Mamun Madaser
Oct 18, 2023
Jim Watson
How to mitigate the risk of cyber security breaches – part 2
Oct 18, 2023
Jim Watson
Oct 18, 2023
Jim Watson
Oct 13, 2023
Nisha Sanghani
Risk management and internal controls: much (needed) work to do as a result of the proposed changes to the UK Corporate Governance Code
Oct 13, 2023
Nisha Sanghani
Oct 13, 2023
Nisha Sanghani
Oct 9, 2023
Jim Watson
How to mitigate the risk of cyber security breaches – part 1
Oct 9, 2023
Jim Watson
Oct 9, 2023
Jim Watson